You Own the Store. Who Keeps the Insurance Income?

Share This Post

Your self-storage property generates more than rental income. It builds a brand, customer relationships and valuable ancillary revenue streams that can contribute directly to net operating income (NOI) and long-term property value.

When you hire a management company, the question isn’t simply what you’ll pay in management fees. It’s how much additional value that management relationship will create and how much of that value you’ll retain.

Download our owner brief, You Own the Store. Who Keeps the Insurance Income?, to see the documented examples and Cubix case study behind this article.

Look Beyond the Management Fee

A management proposal with a competitive fee can look attractive. But the fee alone does not show the full financial picture.

Owners should also review insurance income allocation, marketing expenses, technology charges, payroll reimbursements and termination costs.

Tenant insurance deserves particular attention because the agreement can determine whether the owner participates in that income at all.

A 2015 SEC filing by Strategic Storage Growth Trust, Inc. provides a documented example. In describing its management arrangements with Extra Space Storage, the filing stated that Extra Space held the exclusive right to offer tenant insurance and “is entitled to all of the benefits of such tenant insurance.”

The disclosure also explained that the owner had previously received fees of approximately 50% of tenant premiums. Under the Extra Space arrangement, those revenues went to Extra Space.

These were historical terms from a specific arrangement. Current agreements may differ. The example illustrates why owners should ask for the insurance provisions in writing and evaluate them alongside the management fee.

Management Can Be Part of a Larger Growth Strategy

For some large storage operators, third party management connects with lending and acquisitions.

Extra Space reported that 92% of its 2024 acquisitions came through joint ventures, third party partners or bridge loan relationships. CubeSmart’s 2017 annual report described approximately $600 million in acquisitions from its management program between 2010 and 2017.

These relationships do not mean every managed property will be acquired. They do give owners a reason to understand how their property fits into a prospective manager’s business strategy.

Does the arrangement support your long term ownership goals? What options will you retain if your plans change?

What Cubix Owners Keep

Cubix manages properties to grow their value for the owner.

Our approach includes keeping the facility’s brand and passing 100% of Cubix’s insurance commission to the property owner. Payroll and paid advertising expenses are reimbursed at actual cost without markup. Stabilized properties have no buyout fee.

Our management platform, Cubix Cortex™, is designed to maximize net operating income (NOI) through dynamic pricing, revenue management, tenant insurance, ancillary income opportunities and disciplined expense controls. Across our portfolio, we’ve maintained approximately 92% average occupancy for 12 consecutive quarters, with a target NOI margin of 65%–70%.

The distinction between insurance premiums and insurance commission matters. Passing through our commission does not mean the owner receives every dollar collected from tenants before insurance costs.

Clear definitions help owners compare proposals accurately.

A Concrete Example from Rohnert Park

The Rohnert Park case study in our owner brief reports occupancy increasing from below 70% to 94%, revenue growth of 18.8% in 2022, a 24% increase in rent per square foot and 20% lower operating expenses.

According to Cubix Cortex, the facility collected roughly $129,000 in gross tenant insurance receipts from December 2023 through October 14, 2026.

That amount includes payments for new enrollments and renewals before carrier costs, refunds and accounting adjustments. It is not net insurance commission retained by the owner.

The results show why an owner’s review should extend beyond rent and occupancy. Insurance activity, operating expenses and other income sources all deserve visibility.

Read more about the user case here.

What Additional Income Can Mean for Property Value

The benefit can extend beyond monthly cash flow. Appraisers typically include a market based management expense when estimating net operating income, even when the owner manages the property personally. Avoiding a management fee therefore does not automatically translate into a higher appraised value.

Additional recurring income can increase property value when it raises sustainable net operating income after related costs. If a management partner generates enough additional net income to cover its fee, with other operating factors unchanged, the owner could maintain cash flow, reduce daily management responsibilities and own a more valuable property.

For example, an additional $1,000 in monthly net operating income equals $12,000 annually. At a 6% capitalization rate, that supports approximately $200,000 in additional property value, assuming the income is sustainable and the cap rate remains unchanged.

When comparing management options, consider both what you pay and the additional income and value the relationship can create.

Ask What You Keep Before You Sign

When comparing management proposals, ask:

  1. Can I retain my facility’s name, signage and identity?
  2. Who receives tenant insurance income, and how is that income defined?
  3. Which expenses are billed separately, and do they include markups?
  4. What will it cost to end the agreement?
  5. How will I see the results and understand the decisions affecting my property?
  6. How will the management plan improve sustainable net operating income and support property value?

A management relationship should make those answers clear.

Cubix offers a complimentary Store Leak Audit and Three Year Pro Format to help owners assess rates, occupancy, tenant insurance, ancillary income, marketing expenses and lead conversion.

To discuss your property, contact consulting@cubixstorage.com or visit cubixassetmanagement.com.

Sources

1. Strategic Storage Growth Trust, Inc., 2015 SEC filing

Historical Extra Space management arrangement and tenant insurance provisions.

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1575428/000119312515375996/d30131d10q.htm

2. Extra Space Storage, 2024 Annual Report

Management program and acquisition relationships.

https://annualreport.extraspace.com/annualreport/2024/growth.html

3. CubeSmart, 2017 Annual Report

Acquisitions from its third party management program.

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1298675/000155837018002945/cube-20171231xARS.htm

4. Cubix Rohnert Park case study and internal operational records

Source for facility operating results and gross tenant insurance receipts. The receipts figure does not establish net insurance commission or the percentage of management fees offset.

5. KO Appraisal, Self Storage Appraisal

Discussion of normalizing operating expenses using market evidence, including differences in management arrangements.

https://koappraisal.com/guides/self-storage-appraisal

About the Author

Bridgette Venezia Shortall

Bridgette Venezia is a digital project manager at Cubix Asset Management, where she supports marketing operations, content strategy, and digital initiatives across the firm’s self storage portfolio. She focuses on translating creative concepts into structured, scalable systems that support performance, consistency, and execution. Bridgette brings a multidisciplinary background shaped by formal training in visual storytelling and hands on experience building consumer facing brands. At Cubix, she works closely with internal teams and partners to support thought leadership, website strategy, and marketing infrastructure that aligns with the company’s operational standards and long term growth objectives.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best!

*By submitting this form, you agree to receive marketing and other communications from Cubix Asset Management via email, SMS, or phone. You can opt-out anytime. View our Privacy Policy for details.

// Unlocking Maximum Enterprise Value with Our Best-in-Class Curated Tech Stack | Download

Fill out the form below to get instant access!